Few would dispute that urban expansion is a sign of national development; yet, the moment the dimension of space extension becomes a filter for judging suitability, the debate surrounding advantages and disadvantages of horizontal and vertical city models becomes more intense. Thus, there is little consensus on whether horizontal or vertical cities are ideal places to live in. The following essay will analyse both views before presenting my opinion, which posits the suitability of each model depends on personal preference for the living space.
On one side of the debate, advocates of horizonal towns ground their argument in the conviction that population density would decrease in these areas. By expanding the city by diameter, the government can decrease the number of households per squared kilometer, rather than sealing citizens in narrow apartments. This eases financial burdens on social welfare systems, such as educational institutions, and healthcare services. Nowhere is this more evident than in Europe, where equal population distribution in diameter-extended cities helps to support equal social resource allocation. It is the preference for horizonal cities that has also encouraged empty land utilization in surrounding areas, creating an equal development rate in many regions, instead of watching the shadow of city-centre-based skyscapers hide under-developed outskirts. The U.S.’s experience with horizonal expansion, with additional housing and other essential facilities constantly constructed in the suburban areas, has been an examplary undertaking of this.
However, the argument for horizonal cities may become weaker if it ignores land shortage. On the flip side, proponents of vertical urbanization root their concerns in the increasing housing needs in small countries. Horizonal development requires an abundant amount of non-in-use land, which is not always available all countries. Singapore is, for example, known for overcoming housing needs by erecting many skyscapers and tall housing facilities. This approach meets housing needs and provides more available offices, indoor public places, and necessary amenities in a limited area. As a result, facility-related issues, such as homelessness and the thirst for for-lease workplace, are tackled efficiently. Besides, vertical cities do not address the need of space alone; rather, there are other aspects, such as clear functionality of segmented areas, specific long-term purposes of buildings, and road network designation that simultaneously support real estate market management.
In light of competing perspectives, to either dismiss horizontal and vertical cities is reductive, if not flat out wrong. Admittedly, horizontally extended metropolises decrease population density and reinforce equal resource distribution. Acknowledging this, however, should not blind us to the desire housing and specifically functional facilities in countries with limited land resource. It stands to reason that vertical cities offer more high-capacity buildings and facilitate long-term urban planning. For each model brings about different benefits, it is important for accommodation seekers to make the decision based on their personal expections, preferences, and demands.
