The Role Of Accidents In Business - IELTS Reading Answers & Explanations
From IELTS Vol 1 Academic Reading Test 2 · Part 3 · Questions 27–40
Reading Passage
You should spend about 20 minutes on Questions 27-40, which are based on Reading Passage 3 below.
The role of accidents in business
In 1894 Dr John Kellogg and his brother, Will, were supervising a hospital and health spa in Michigan. The patients were on a restricted diet. One day, the brothers left cooked wheat untended for more than 24 hours. When they returned, they saw what they had done. It was no good to eat, but they decided to run the stale wheat through rollers, just to see how it would turn out. Normally, the process produced long sheets, but they were surprised to discover that this time the rollers created flat flakes. They baked them, and then tried the same thing with corn. From this accidental discovery came the cornflakes that generations have now been eating for breakfast.
Accidents happen; there is nothing predictable and orderly about innovation. Nobel laureate Sir Alan Hodgkin, who discovered how nerve cells transmit electrical impulses between the skin and the brain, commented: ‘I believe that the record of my published papers conveys an impression of directedness and planning which does not at all coincide with the actual sequence of events.’
The same rule applies in business. The mistake that gave us cornflakes keeps repeating itself in the history of disruptive innovation, the kind that transforms markets. Louis Daguerre, for instance, discovered the technique that gave us photography in the 1830s, when drops of mercury from a shattered thermometer produced a photographic image. The microwave was discovered when Percy Spencer, a scientist with Raytheon, was testing a new vacuum tube and discovered that the sweet in his pocket had melted. The artificial sweetener, saccharin, was the unintentional result of a medical scientist’s work on a chemical treatment for gastric ulcers. While working for the firm 3M, researcher Art Fry had no idea he was taking the first steps towards Post-It Notes when he used bits of adhesive office paper that could be easily lifted off the page to replace the scrap paper bookmarks that kept falling out of his hymn book.
Breakthrough and disruptive innovation are rarely driven by orderly process. Usually they come out of a chaotic, haphazard mess, which is why big companies, full of managers schooled in business programmes designed to eliminate random variation and mistakes, struggle with them. In these sorts of environments, accidents are called failures and are discouraged.
It is no surprise then that research from the late British economist Paul Geroski and London Business School’s Constantinos Markides found that companies that were skilled at innovation were usually not that skilled when it came to commercialisation, and vice versa. Their book, Fast Second, divides businesses into ‘colonists’ and ‘consolidators’. Small and nimble, colonists are adept at creating market niches but are terrible institution builders. Consolidators, with their strong cultures of discipline and cost control, know how to take clever ideas from other firms and turn them into mass-market items. Microsoft is a prime instance of this.
With companies spending hundreds of billions of dollars on research and development, US academics Robert Austin and Lee Devin examined how managers can encourage productive slip-ups. In their article Accident, Intention and Expectation in the Innovation Process, they argue that business processes actually prevent helpful mis-steps from occurring. According to their catalogue of accidents, not all false steps and mishaps are equal. Accidents, they say, come from unlikely mental associations such as memories and vague connections, looking for something and finding it in an unexpected way, looking for one thing and finding something else, and not looking for anything but finding something valuable.
Accident-prone innovation, they say, requires companies to get outside the ‘cone of expectation’. It means throwing together groups from diverse backgrounds, and combining ideas in unpredictable ways. Other strategies also include having systems that watch out for accidents and examine them for value, generating them when they do not happen often enough, seizing on the useful ones, capturing their valuable features, and building on them to add value and give potential for useful accidents.
All this, however, requires thinking that is often counter-intuitive to the way businesses operate. In other words, it is the kind of thinking that goes against the beliefs of most business managers. It runs counter to the notion frequently pushed by consultants that you can ‘harness’ creativity and direct it to line up with intention. ‘The cost of accidents that do not prove valuable is often of concern to people in business’, they write. ‘In business, people tend to call such efforts failure.’
There are tentative signs that more companies are starting to realise that failure can lead to commercial gain, and that this is part of the risk-taking that underpins innovation. Australia’s largest brewing company, for example, made a bad error when it launched a new beer called Empire Lager, pitched at younger consumers. Having spent a fortune creating a beer with a sweeter taste, designing a great-looking bottle and a television campaign, Foster’s was left with a drink that no-one wanted to buy. The target market was more interested in brands built up by word of mouth.
Instead of wiping the unsuccessful product launch, Fosters used this lesson learned to go on and develop other brands instead. One of them, Pure Blonde, is now ranked as Australia’s fifth-largest beer brand. Unlike Empire Lager, there has been almost no promotion and its sales are generated more by word of mouth.
Other companies are taking similar steps to study their own slip-ups. Intuit, the company behind financial tools such as Quicken, holds regular ‘When Learning Hurts’ sessions. But this sort of transformation is never easy. In a market that focuses on the short-term, convincing employees and shareholders to tolerate failure and not play it safe is a big thing to ask.
Questions
Questions 27–31 Yes / No / Not Given
Do the following statements agree with the claims of the writer in Reading Passage 3?
Choose
YES if the statement agrees with the claims of the writer
NO if the statement contradicts the claims of the writer
NOT GIVEN if it is impossible to say what the writer thinks about this
Questions 32–35 Matching Sentence Endings
Complete each sentence with the correct ending, A-H, below.
A. can be found in unusual thoughts and chance events.
B. can be taught in business schools.
C. has made a success from someone else’s invention.
D. is designed to nurture differences.
E. is unlikely to lead to creative innovation.
F. says that all mistakes are the same.
G. shows that businesses are good at either inventing or selling.
H. suggests ways of increasing the number of mistakes.
Questions 36–40 One Choice
Choose the correct letter, A, B, C or D.
Answers & Explanations Summary
| # | Answer | Evidence | Explanation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Q27 | YES | Normally, the process produced long sheets, but they were surprised to discover that this time the rollers created flat flakes | Excerpt/Passage Explanation: The passage says the process normally made long sheets, but this time the rollers made flat flakes. Answer Explanation: The answer is YES because the wheat was left for a long time and that changed what came out. Reason For Correctness: The correct answer is YES because 'left cooked wheat untended for more than 24 hours' is the delay, and the result was 'flat flakes' instead of long sheets. |
| Q28 | NO | ‘I believe that the record of my published papers conveys an impression of directedness and planning which does not at all coincide with the actual sequence of events.’ | Excerpt/Passage Explanation: The passage quotes Hodgkin saying his papers look planned and direct, but this is not what really happened. Answer Explanation: The answer is NO because Hodgkin's work did not go forward in a logical, planned way. Reason For Correctness: The correct answer is NO because 'does not at all coincide with the actual sequence of events' contradicts 'logical and systematic'. |
| Q29 | NO | The mistake that gave us cornflakes keeps repeating itself in the history of disruptive innovation, the kind that transforms markets | Excerpt/Passage Explanation: The passage says the cornflakes mistake keeps happening in the history of big innovations, and then gives Daguerre as an example. Answer Explanation: The answer is NO because Daguerre follows the general rule, so he is not an exception. Reason For Correctness: The correct answer is NO because 'for instance' introduces Daguerre as an example of the rule, which is the opposite of 'an exception'. |
| Q30 | YES | The artificial sweetener, saccharin, was the unintentional result of a medical scientist’s work on a chemical treatment for gastric ulcers | Excerpt/Passage Explanation: The passage says saccharin was an unplanned result of a scientist's work on a treatment for ulcers. Answer Explanation: The answer is YES because saccharin was found by accident during medical research. Reason For Correctness: The correct answer is YES because 'unintentional' matches 'by accident' and 'chemical treatment for gastric ulcers' matches 'drug research'. |
| Q31 | NOT GIVEN | While working for the firm 3M, researcher Art Fry had no idea he was taking the first steps towards Post-It Notes when he used bits of adhesive office paper that could be easily lifted off the page to replace the scrap paper bookmarks that kept falling out of his hymn book | Excerpt/Passage Explanation: The passage says Art Fry, working at 3M, started Post-It Notes by using sticky paper as bookmarks, but it says nothing about funding. Answer Explanation: The answer is NOT GIVEN because the writer gives no opinion on whether 3M should have funded his idea. Reason For Correctness: The correct answer is NOT GIVEN because the passage never mentions money or support from 3M for Art Fry. |
| Q32 | E | Usually they come out of a chaotic, haphazard mess, which is why big companies, full of managers schooled in business programmes designed to eliminate random variation and mistakes, struggle with them | Excerpt/Passage Explanation: The passage says big companies, with managers trained to remove mistakes, struggle with innovation, which comes from a messy process. Answer Explanation: The answer is E, which means the usual business environment is unlikely to lead to creative innovation. Reason For Correctness: The correct answer is E because 'struggle with them' matches 'unlikely to lead to', and 'accidents are called failures and are discouraged' shows the same. |
| Q33 | G | found that companies that were skilled at innovation were usually not that skilled when it came to commercialisation, and vice versa | Excerpt/Passage Explanation: The passage says the research found that companies good at innovation are usually not good at selling, and the reverse. Answer Explanation: The answer is G, which means the book shows that businesses are good at either inventing or selling. Reason For Correctness: The correct answer is G because 'innovation' matches 'inventing', 'commercialisation' matches 'selling', and 'vice versa' matches 'either ... or'. |
| Q34 | C | Consolidators, with their strong cultures of discipline and cost control, know how to take clever ideas from other firms and turn them into mass-market items. Microsoft is a prime instance of this | Excerpt/Passage Explanation: The passage says some companies take clever ideas from other firms and make them into mass-market products, and Microsoft is one of them. Answer Explanation: The answer is C, which means Microsoft has succeeded using someone else's invention. Reason For Correctness: The correct answer is C because 'take clever ideas from other firms' matches 'someone else's invention'. |
| Q35 | A | Accidents, they say, come from unlikely mental associations such as memories and vague connections, looking for something and finding it in an unexpected way, looking for one thing and finding something else, and not looking for anything but finding something valuable | Excerpt/Passage Explanation: The passage says accidents come from unlikely mental links, unexpected ways of finding things and finding something valuable when not looking. Answer Explanation: The answer is A, which means useful accidents come from unusual thoughts and chance events. Reason For Correctness: The correct answer is A because 'unlikely mental associations' matches 'unusual thoughts', and 'finding something else' matches 'chance events'. |
| Q36 | B | It means throwing together groups from diverse backgrounds, and combining ideas in unpredictable ways | Excerpt/Passage Explanation: The passage says getting out of the 'cone of expectation' means putting together groups of people from different backgrounds. Answer Explanation: The answer is B, which means companies should form teams of different types of people. Reason For Correctness: The correct answer is B because 'groups from diverse backgrounds' matches 'teams of different types of people'. |
| Q37 | D | ‘The cost of accidents that do not prove valuable is often of concern to people in business’, they write | Excerpt/Passage Explanation: The passage quotes Austin and Devin saying that business people often worry about the cost of accidents that turn out to be useless. Answer Explanation: The answer is D, which means the cost of mistakes is an important consideration. Reason For Correctness: The correct answer is D because 'often of concern' matches 'an important consideration', and the passage says this is how most managers think. |
| Q38 | A | Instead of wiping the unsuccessful product launch, Fosters used this lesson learned to go on and develop other brands instead | Excerpt/Passage Explanation: The passage says Fosters did not forget its failed launch. It used the lesson to develop other brands. Answer Explanation: The answer is A, which means success can come out of a business failure. Reason For Correctness: The correct answer is A because 'used this lesson learned to go on and develop other brands' shows that the failure led to later success. |
| Q39 | C | Unlike Empire Lager, there has been almost no promotion and its sales are generated more by word of mouth | Excerpt/Passage Explanation: The passage says Pure Blonde had almost no promotion and its sales came mostly from word of mouth. Answer Explanation: The answer is C, which means Pure Blonde was launched with very little advertising. Reason For Correctness: The correct answer is C because 'almost no promotion' matches 'very little advertising'. |
| Q40 | B | But this sort of transformation is never easy. In a market that focuses on the short-term, convincing employees and shareholders to tolerate failure and not play it safe is a big thing to ask | Excerpt/Passage Explanation: The passage says this change is never easy, because it is hard to convince employees and shareholders to accept failure. Answer Explanation: The answer is B, which means creating a culture that learns from mistakes can be very difficult for some companies. Reason For Correctness: The correct answer is B because 'never easy' and 'a big thing to ask' match 'very difficult'. |
