What Makes A Musical Expert? - IELTS Reading Answers & Explanations
From IELTS Vol 1 Academic Reading Test 1 · Part 3 · Questions 27–40
Reading Passage
You should spend about 20 minutes on Questions 27-40, which are based on Reading Passage 3 below.
What makes a musical expert?
How does someone become expert in music? And is it really possible to have a ‘talent’ for music?
Does that class of people acknowledged to be musical experts just have more of the same basic skills we are all endowed with, or do they have a set of abilities - or neural structures - that are totally different from those of the rest of us? Are high levels of musical achievement simply the result of training and practice, or are they based on innate brain structure - what we refer to as ‘talent’? Talent can be defined as something that originates in genetic structures and that is identifiable by trained people who can recognize its existence before a person has achieved exceptional levels of performance. The emphasis on early identification means that to investigate it, we study the development of skills in children.
It is evident that some children acquire skills more rapidly than others: the age of onset for walking and talking varies widely, even between children in the same household. There may be genetic factors at work, but these are closely linked with other factors - with a presumably environmental component - such as motivation and family dynamics. Similar factors can influence musical development and can mask the contribution of genetics to musical ability.
Brain studies, so far, haven’t been of much use in sorting out the issues. Gottfried Schlaug at Harvard collected brain scans of individuals with absolute pitch* (AP) and showed that a region in the brain called the planum temporale is larger in these people than in others. This suggests that the planum is involved in AP, but it’s not clear if it starts out larger in people who eventually acquire AP, or if the acquisition of AP makes the planum increase in size.
Results of research into the areas of the brain involved in skilled motor movement are more conclusive. Studies of violin players have shown that the region of the brain responsible for controlling the movement of the left hand (the hand that requires greater precision in violin playing) increases in size as a result of practice. We do not know yet if the propensity for increase pre-exists in some people and not others.
The evidence against talent comes from research on how much training the experts do. Like experts in mathematics, chess, or sports, experts in music require lengthy periods of instruction and practice. In several studies, the very best music students were found to have practiced more than twice as much as the others. In another study, students were secretly divided into two groups based on teachers’ perceptions of their talent. Several years later, it was found that the students who achieved the highest performance ratings had practiced the most, irrespective of which ‘talent’ group they had been assigned to, suggesting that practice does not merely correlate with achievement, but causes it.
Anders Ericsson, at Florida State University, approaches the topic of musical expertise as a general problem in cognitive psychology. He takes as a starting point the assumption that there are certain issues involved in becoming an expert at anything; that we can learn about musical expertise by studying expert chess players, athletes, artists, mathematicians, as well as the musicians themselves. The emerging picture from such studies is that ten thousand hours of practice is required to achieve the level of mastery associated with being a world-class expert - in anything. In study after study, of composers, ice skaters, concert pianists, chess players and master criminals, this number comes up again and again. Someone would do this amount of practice if they practiced, for example, roughly 20 hours a week for ten years. Of course, this does not address why some people do not seem to get anywhere when they practice, and why some people get more out of their practice sessions than others. But no-one has yet found a case in which true world-class expertise was accomplished in less time. It seems that it takes the brain this long to assimilate all that it needs to know to achieve true mastery.
The ten-thousand-hour theory is consistent with what we know about how the brain learns. Learning requires the assimilation and consolidation of information in neural tissue. The more experiences we have with something, the stronger the memory/learning trace for that experience becomes. Although people differ in how long it takes them to consolidate information neurally, it remains true that increased practice leads to a greater number of neural traces, which create stronger memory representation.
The classic rebuttal to this theory goes something like this: ‘What about Mozart? I hear that he composed his first symphony at the age of four!’ First, there is a factual error here: Mozart did not write it until he was eight. Still, this is unusual, to say the least. However, this early work received little acclaim and was not performed very often. In fact, the only reason we know about it is because the child who wrote it grew up to become Mozart. And Mozart had an expert teacher in his father, who was renowned as a teacher of musicians all over Europe. We do not know how much Mozart practiced, but if he started at age two and worked thirty-two hours a week (quite possible, given that his father was a stern taskmaster) he would have made his ten thousand hours by the time he composed his first symphony. This does not mean that there are no genetic factors involved in Mozart’s greatness, but that inborn traits may not be the only cause.
* individuals with absolute pitch: people who can identify or sing any musical note correctly without help
Questions
Questions 27–30 One Choice
Choose the correct letter, A, B, C or D.
Questions 31–36 Yes / No / Not Given
Do the following statements agree with the claims of the writer in Reading Passage 3?
YES if the statement agrees with the claims of the writer
NO if the statement contradicts the claims of the writer
NOT GIVEN if it is impossible to say what the writer thinks about this
Questions 37–40 Summary Completion
Complete the summary using the list of words, A-J, below.
A. popular | B. artistic | C. completed
D. eight | E. tuition | F. encouragement
G. inherited | H. four | I. practice
J. two
Mozart
The case of Mozart could be quoted as evidence against the 10,000-hour-practice theory. However, the writer points out that the young Mozart received a lot of 37 from his father, and that the symphony he wrote at the age of 38 was not 39 and may be of only academic interest. The case therefore supports the view that expertise is not solely the result of 40 characteristics.
Answers & Explanations Summary
| # | Answer | Evidence | Explanation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Q27 | B | or do they have a set of abilities - or neural structures - that are totally different from those of the rest of us? Are high levels of musical achievement simply the result of training and practice, or are they based on innate brain structure - what we refer to as ‘talent’ | Excerpt/Passage Explanation: The passage asks if musical experts have brain structures that are totally different from other people's. It then says this inborn brain structure is what we call 'talent'. Answer Explanation: The answer is B, which means a talented musician is someone whose brain is built differently from the brains of other people. Reason For Correctness: The correct answer is B because the writer calls 'innate brain structure' talent, and 'totally different from those of the rest of us' matches 'unlike that of other people'. C is wrong because talent can be seen before a person performs very well. |
| Q28 | C | This suggests that the planum is involved in AP, but it’s not clear if it starts out larger in people who eventually acquire AP, or if the acquisition of AP makes the planum increase in size | Excerpt/Passage Explanation: The passage says the planum seems linked to absolute pitch, but we do not know if it is large first or grows because of the skill. Answer Explanation: The answer is C, which means it is unclear whether a brain feature is a cause or an effect of a musical skill. Reason For Correctness: The correct answer is C because 'starts out larger' is a cause and 'acquisition of AP makes the planum increase' is an effect. |
| Q29 | A | Studies of violin players have shown that the region of the brain responsible for controlling the movement of the left hand (the hand that requires greater precision in violin playing) increases in size as a result of practice | Excerpt/Passage Explanation: The passage says studies of violin players show that the brain area for the left hand gets bigger because of practice. Answer Explanation: The answer is A, which means the brain can change after violin practice. Reason For Correctness: The correct answer is A because 'increases in size as a result of practice' matches 'Changes may occur in the brain following violin practice'. |
| Q30 | A | The evidence against talent comes from research on how much training the experts do | Excerpt/Passage Explanation: The passage says that the evidence against talent comes from studies of how much the experts train. Answer Explanation: The answer is A, which means talent may have little to do with expertise. Reason For Correctness: The correct answer is A because 'evidence against talent' matches 'little to do with', and the studies show practice is what matters. |
| Q31 | NOT GIVEN | Anders Ericsson, at Florida State University, approaches the topic of musical expertise as a general problem in cognitive psychology | Excerpt/Passage Explanation: The passage says Anders Ericsson studies musical expertise as part of cognitive psychology, but it does not say who he influenced. Answer Explanation: The answer is NOT GIVEN because the passage does not say whether other researchers were influenced by him. Reason For Correctness: The correct answer is NOT GIVEN because the text describes his approach only. There is no word like 'influenced' or any mention of other researchers following him. |
| Q32 | YES | The emerging picture from such studies is that ten thousand hours of practice is required to achieve the level of mastery associated with being a world-class expert - in anything | Excerpt/Passage Explanation: The passage says studies show that ten thousand hours of practice are needed to become a world-class expert in anything. Answer Explanation: The answer is YES because many fields share the same need for ten thousand hours. Reason For Correctness: The correct answer is YES because 'in anything' matches 'different areas of expertise', and the shared point is the ten thousand hours. |
| Q33 | NOT GIVEN | Someone would do this amount of practice if they practiced, for example, roughly 20 hours a week for ten years | Excerpt/Passage Explanation: The passage gives an example of 20 hours of practice a week for ten years, but it does not say practice must happen every day. Answer Explanation: The answer is NOT GIVEN because the passage does not say practice must be done daily to be useful. Reason For Correctness: The correct answer is NOT GIVEN because the passage talks about total hours, not about 'every day' or whether practice is only useful when regular. |
| Q34 | NO | Of course, this does not address why some people do not seem to get anywhere when they practice, and why some people get more out of their practice sessions than others | Excerpt/Passage Explanation: The passage says that some people do not get anywhere when they practice, and others get more from practice than others. Answer Explanation: The answer is NO because practising for a long time does not always make a person a world-class expert. Reason For Correctness: The correct answer is NO because 'do not seem to get anywhere when they practice' contradicts 'Anyone who practices for long enough can reach' that level. |
| Q35 | NO | But no-one has yet found a case in which true world-class expertise was accomplished in less time | Excerpt/Passage Explanation: The passage says nobody has found a person who became a true world-class expert in less time. Answer Explanation: The answer is NO because the passage says this has never been found. Reason For Correctness: The correct answer is NO because 'no-one has yet found a case' contradicts 'Occasionally, someone can become an expert', and 'less time' matches 'fewer than 10,000 hours'. |
| Q36 | YES | The ten-thousand-hour theory is consistent with what we know about how the brain learns | Excerpt/Passage Explanation: The passage says the ten-thousand-hour theory agrees with what we know about how the brain learns. Answer Explanation: The answer is YES because what we know about learning supports the importance of practice. Reason For Correctness: The correct answer is YES because 'consistent with what we know' matches 'Existing knowledge ... supports', and the theory is about practice. |
| Q37 | E | And Mozart had an expert teacher in his father, who was renowned as a teacher of musicians all over Europe | Excerpt/Passage Explanation: The passage says Mozart had an expert teacher, his father, who taught musicians all over Europe. Answer Explanation: The answer is E, tuition, which means teaching. Reason For Correctness: The correct answer is E because 'received a lot of tuition from his father' matches 'had an expert teacher in his father'. |
| Q38 | D | First, there is a factual error here: Mozart did not write it until he was eight | Excerpt/Passage Explanation: The passage says Mozart wrote his first symphony when he was eight, not four. Answer Explanation: The answer is D, eight, which is the age when he wrote the symphony. Reason For Correctness: The correct answer is D because the passage corrects the claim of age four and says 'until he was eight'. |
| Q39 | A | However, this early work received little acclaim and was not performed very often | Excerpt/Passage Explanation: The passage says the early symphony got little praise and was not often performed. Answer Explanation: The answer is A, popular, which means liked by many people. Reason For Correctness: The correct answer is A because 'not popular' matches 'received little acclaim and was not performed very often'. |
| Q40 | G | This does not mean that there are no genetic factors involved in Mozart’s greatness, but that inborn traits may not be the only cause | Excerpt/Passage Explanation: The passage says genes may play a part in Mozart's greatness, but inborn traits may not be the only cause. Answer Explanation: The answer is G, inherited, which means passed down from parents. Reason For Correctness: The correct answer is G because 'inborn traits' and 'genetic factors' are both about inherited characteristics, and they are not the only cause. |
