In the contemporary era, students are not only required to be good at studying academically but also in practical aspects. Therefore, many assume that some voluntary activities should be added as a compulsory part of the curriculum in high school. While I acknowledge that uncompensated community services can bring numerous benefits for the overall development of students, I still believe it is not a good idea to force every high school student to volunteer as a part of their programmes.
On the one hand, integrating unpaid community service into school could significantly benefit learners in various ways. To begin with, it enables individuals to develop life skills. When working for the community, students have the chance to learn hands-on knowledge that not any books can teach them. They can learn how to work in a team, express their thoughts, be disciplined, etc; these are among the essential skills that will help them live easier in further life. Additionally, volunteering plays a vital role in developing students with strong responsibility and empathy . My cousin, who is in the case, after being involved in a clean-up program in her school, gained a profound respect for the tireless effort of the janitors who need to maintain the cleanliness of the town everyday. As a result, by observing, and directly attending the voluntary work, students can learn many valuable lessons about hard work, dedication, and responsibility.
On the other hand, making unpaid community service a compulsory part of school curriculum can bring about some unintended consequences. First and foremost, this requires such a huge amount of students’ time and effort that can undermine their academic performances. High school students are expected to attend classes, complete assignments, and prepare for such a serious examination to get into university, etc, all of which require considerable time and concentration. If they are forced to participate in community services, they will have less time to review their lessons and undergird their knowledge leading to poor performance at school. Moreover, this policy could exacerbate the financial disparities among students within school. Despite the fact that these programs are originally designed to give equal opportunities for every student, taking part in these kinds of programs still requires some indirect costs, like transportation, materials, meals, etc, which may create numerous difficulties for financially disadvantaged families. Meanwhile, students with wealthy backgrounds are more likely to meet all the demands to volunteer and study at the same time without any disruption. As a result, rather than developing equality and personal development, compulsory unpaid community activities can burden underprivileged students, even widening the educational gap between different family backgrounds.
In conclusion, it is admitted that incorporating voluntary activities can bring certain advantages, such as developing soft skills, and raising a sense of responsibility. However, this approach should be reconsidered carefully before being implemented. Such a requirement could take time away from academic studies and, more importantly, exacerbate socioeconomic inequalities by placing disadvantaged students at a greater disadvantage. Therefore, I personally think that these activities should remain optional rather than being imposed on all students.
