Preface To ‘How The Other Half Thinks: - IELTS Reading Answers & Explanations
From Cambridge IELTS 11 Academic Reading Test 3 · Part 3 · Questions 27–40
Reading Passage
Preface to ‘How the other half thinks:
Adventures in mathematical reasoning’
A
Occasionally, in some difficult musical compositions, there are beautiful, but easy parts – parts so simple a beginner could play them. So it is with mathematics as well. There are some discoveries in advanced mathematics that do not depend on specialized knowledge, not even on algebra, geometry, or trigonometry. Instead they may involve, at most, a little arithmetic, such as ‘the sum of two odd numbers is even’, and common sense. Each of the eight chapters in this book illustrates this phenomenon. Anyone can understand every step in the reasoning.
The thinking in each chapter uses at most only elementary arithmetic, and sometimes not even that. Thus all readers will have the chance to participate in a mathematical experience, to appreciate the beauty of mathematics, and to become familiar with its logical, yet intuitive, style of thinking.
B
One of my purposes in writing this book is to give readers who haven’t had the opportunity to see and enjoy real mathematics the chance to appreciate the mathematical way of thinking. I want to reveal not only some of the fascinating discoveries, but, more importantly, the reasoning behind them.
In that respect, this book differs from most books on mathematics written for the general public. Some present the lives of colorful mathematicians. Others describe important applications of mathematics. Yet others go into mathematical procedures, but assume that the reader is adept in using algebra.
C
I hope this book will help bridge that notorious gap that separates the two cultures: the humanities and the sciences, or should I say the right brain (intuitive) and the left brain (analytical, numerical). As the chapters will illustrate, mathematics is not restricted to the analytical and numerical; intuition plays a significant role. The alleged gap can be narrowed or completely overcome by anyone, in part because each of us is far from using the full capacity of either side of the brain. To illustrate our human potential, I cite a structural engineer who is an artist, an electrical engineer who is an opera singer, an opera singer who published mathematical research, and a mathematician who publishes short stories.
D
Other scientists have written books to explain their fields to non-scientists, but have necessarily had to omit the mathematics, although it provides the foundation of their theories. The reader must remain a tantalized spectator rather than an involved participant, since the appropriate language for describing the details in much of science is mathematics, whether the subject is expanding universe, subatomic particles, or chromosomes. Though the broad outline of a scientific theory can be sketched intuitively, when a part of the physical universe is finally understood, its description often looks like a page in a mathematics text.
E
Still, the non-mathematical reader can go far in understanding mathematical reasoning. This book presents the details that illustrate the mathematical style of thinking, which involves sustained, step-by-step analysis, experiments, and insights. You will turn these pages much more slowly than when reading a novel or a newspaper. It may help to have a pencil and paper ready to check claims and carry out experiments.
F
As I wrote, I kept in mind two types of readers: those who enjoyed mathematics until they were turned off by an unpleasant episode, usually around fifth grade, and mathematics aficionados, who will find much that is new throughout the book.
This book also serves readers who simply want to sharpen their analytical skills. Many careers, such as law and medicine, require extended, precise analysis. Each chapter offers practice in following a sustained and closely argued line of thought. That mathematics can develop this skill is shown by these two testimonials:
G
A physician wrote, ‘The discipline of analytical thought processes [in mathematics] prepared me extremely well for medical school. In medicine one is faced with a problem which must be thoroughly analyzed before a solution can be found. The process is similar to doing mathematics.’
A lawyer made the same point, “Although I had no background in law – not even one political science course — I did well at one of the best law schools. I attribute much of my success there to having learned, through the study of mathematics, and, in particular, theorems, how to analyze complicated principles. Lawyers who have studied mathematics can master the legal principles in a way that most others cannot.’
I hope you will share my delight in watching as simple, even naive, questions lead to remarkable solutions and purely theoretical discoveries find unanticipated applications.
Questions
Questions 27–34 Matching Information
The Reading Passage has seven sections, A-G.
Which section contains the following information?
Write the correct letter, A-G, in boxes on your answer sheet.
NB You may use any letter more than once.
Questions 35–40 Sentence Completion
Complete the sentences below.
Choose ONE WORD ONLY from the passage for each answer.
Write your answers in boxes on your answer sheet.
- Some areas of both music and mathematics are suitable for someone who is a 35
- It is sometimes possible to understand advanced mathematics using no more than a limited knowledge of 36
- The writer intends to show that mathematics requires 37 thinking, as well as analytical skills.
- Some books written by 38 have had to leave out the mathematics that is central to their theories.
- The writer advises non-mathematical readers to perform 39 while reading
- A lawyer found that studying 40 helped even more than other areas of mathematics in the study of law.
Answers & Explanations Summary
| # | Answer | Evidence | Explanation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Q27 | D | Other scientists have written books to explain their fields to non-scientists, but have necessarily had to omit the mathematics, although it provides the foundation of their theories. | Excerpt/Passage Explanation: The passage talks about scientists who have written books to explain their fields to people who are not scientists. However, these books had to leave out the math that forms the basis of their theories. Answer Explanation: The answer 'D' refers to a section that includes a mention of books that are written assuming readers do not have knowledge of mathematics. Reason For Correctness: The correct answer is D because the excerpt specifically mentions how books written by scientists for non-scientists must exclude mathematics, which implies they assume a lack of mathematical knowledge. This aligns with the description provided in the question where the answer choice 'D' is associated with a reference to books that assume a lack of mathematical knowledge. |
| Q28 | B | In that respect, this book differs from most books on mathematics written for the general public. | Excerpt/Passage Explanation: The passage is saying that this book is different from most other books on mathematics that are written for the general public. Answer Explanation: The answer means section B contains information about how this book is not like typical mathematics books. Reason For Correctness: The correct answer is B because it directly correlates with the given information that states this book is not typical compared to other books on mathematics written for the general public. |
| Q29 | G | Lawyers who have studied mathematics can master the legal principles in a way that most others cannot | Excerpt/Passage Explanation: The passage talks about how studying mathematics can help lawyers understand legal principles better than others. Answer Explanation: The answer indicates that the section containing personal examples of being helped by mathematics is G. Reason For Correctness: The correct answer is G because lawyers benefiting from studying mathematics and understanding legal principles aligns with the theme of personal examples of how mathematics can be helpful. |
| Q30 | C | To illustrate our human potential, I cite a structural engineer who is an artist, an electrical engineer who is an opera singer, an opera singer who published mathematical research, and a mathematician who publishes short stories. | Excerpt/Passage Explanation: The passage talks about different individuals who possess skills or talents in seemingly opposite areas. Answer Explanation: The answer choice C represents the section that describes examples of people having abilities that appear to be incompatible. Reason For Correctness: The correct answer is C because the excerpt specifically mentions a structural engineer who is an artist, an electrical engineer who is an opera singer, an opera singer who published mathematical research, and a mathematician who publishes short stories. These examples demonstrate individuals with diverse talents that may not typically be associated with each other. |
| Q31 | B | Some present the lives of colorful mathematicians. Others describe important applications of mathematics. Yet others go into mathematical procedures, but assume that the reader is adept in using algebra. | Excerpt/Passage Explanation: The passage talks about different types of books about mathematics. Some focus on mathematicians' lives, others on practical uses of math, and some on mathematical procedures assuming knowledge of algebra. Answer Explanation: The answer indicates that the section that mentions different focuses of books about mathematics is section B. Reason For Correctness: The correct answer is B because the excerpt states that different types of books about mathematics exist, each with a specific focus. Section B refers to the mention of different focuses of books about mathematics, aligning with the information provided in the passage. |
| Q32 | E | You will turn these pages much more slowly than when reading a novel or a newspaper. | Excerpt/Passage Explanation: The passage is saying that when you read this book, you will read it more slowly than when you read other things like novels or newspapers. Answer Explanation: The answer is the section E of the passage. Reason For Correctness: The correct answer is E because the excerpt says 'You will turn these pages much more slowly than when reading a novel or a newspaper', which is a contrast between reading this book and reading other kinds of publication, as described in the question. |
| Q33 | A | Anyone can understand every step in the reasoning. | Excerpt/Passage Explanation: The passage is saying that everyone can understand each part of the reasoning presented. Answer Explanation: The answer choice 'A' refers to a claim that the whole book is accessible to everyone. Reason For Correctness: The correct answer is 'A' because it aligns with the statement in the excerpt that suggests complete accessibility and understanding of the content by all individuals, indicating that the book is indeed accessible to everybody. |
| Q34 | F | As I wrote, I kept in mind two types of readers | Excerpt/Passage Explanation: The passage mentioned that the writer thought about two different types of readers. Answer Explanation: The answer refers to a mention of different categories of intended readers for the book. Reason For Correctness: The correct answer is 'F' because the passage directly talks about two types of readers, indicating a categorization or classification of readers based on their characteristics or preferences. |
| Q35 | beginner | Occasionally, in some difficult musical compositions, there are beautiful, but easy parts – parts so simple a beginner could play them. So it is with mathematics as well. | Excerpt/Passage Explanation: The passage says that in some hard music pieces, there are also nice and easy parts that even a beginner can play. It compares this to mathematics, suggesting that some math can also be easy, even when the overall subject is difficult. Answer Explanation: The answer 'beginner' means someone who is new to a subject or activity and doesn't have much experience. In this case, it refers to someone who is just starting to learn music or mathematics. Reason For Correctness: The correct answer 'beginner' fits well because the passage talks about how even difficult things, like music and mathematics, have parts that are simple enough for someone who is just starting to learn. So, a beginner can understand these easier parts. |
| Q36 | arithmetic | There are some discoveries in advanced mathematics that do not depend on specialized knowledge, not even on algebra, geometry, or trigonometry. Instead they may involve, at most, a little arithmetic | Excerpt/Passage Explanation: The passage explains that some advanced mathematical discoveries can be understood without needing specialized knowledge. Instead, basic arithmetic skills might be sufficient. Answer Explanation: The answer 'arithmetic' refers to basic mathematical operations like addition, subtraction, multiplication, and division. Reason For Correctness: The correct answer is 'arithmetic' because the excerpt mentions that certain advanced mathematical concepts do not require in-depth knowledge of algebra, geometry, or trigonometry but may be grasped with just a little arithmetic, emphasizing the importance of simple mathematical calculations in understanding complex ideas. |
| Q37 | intuitive | Thus all readers will have the chance to participate in a mathematical experience, to appreciate the beauty of mathematics, and to become familiar with its logical, yet intuitive, style of thinking. | Excerpt/Passage Explanation: The passage mentions that mathematics has a logical way of thinking but also involves a style of thinking that is based on instinctive feelings or beliefs. Answer Explanation: The answer 'intuitive' refers to thinking influenced more by instincts or feelings rather than pure logic. Reason For Correctness: The correct answer is 'intuitive' because it aligns with the idea that mathematics, in addition to being logical, also requires a certain level of intuitive thinking. This is evident from the mention of mathematics being appreciated for its logical yet intuitive style of thinking in the excerpt. |
| Q38 | scientists | Other scientists have written books to explain their fields to non-scientists, but have necessarily had to omit the mathematics, although it provides the foundation of their theories. | Excerpt/Passage Explanation: The passage is saying that when scientists write books for non-experts, they have to leave out the math parts, even though math is very important to their ideas. Answer Explanation: The answer is 'scientists'. This refers to experts in a particular field of study. Reason For Correctness: The correct answer is 'scientists' because the passage mentions 'Other scientists' who write books for non-experts and have to omit the math parts. |
| Q39 | experiments | It may help to have a pencil and paper ready to check claims and carry out experiments. | Excerpt/Passage Explanation: The passage suggests that it could be helpful to have a pen and paper ready in order to test out claims and conduct experiments. Answer Explanation: The answer means small tests or investigations that can be done to explore or verify something. Reason For Correctness: The correct answer matches the context of the excerpt because 'experiments' refer to practical actions that involve testing or trying things out, which aligns with the suggestion to perform activities like experiments while reading. |
| Q40 | theorems | I attribute much of my success there to having learned, through the study of mathematics, and, in particular, theorems, how to analyze complicated principles. | Excerpt/Passage Explanation: The passage talks about how studying mathematics, specifically theorems, helped the writer analyze complex principles and contributed to their success. Answer Explanation: The answer refers to 'theorems,' which are mathematical statements that have been proven to be true and are essential in mathematical reasoning and problem-solving. Reason For Correctness: The correct answer is 'theorems' because the excerpt explicitly mentions that the study of theorems helped the writer analyze complicated principles, emphasizing the importance of this specific aspect of mathematics in developing analytical skills. |
