There is an ongoing debate among scholars regarding the use of movies and television shows as solid research data for historical studies. Some argue that these media forms lack historical accuracy. However, they can provide a background on the lifestyle of people, depicting their houses, clothes, and historical sites—experiences that researchers cannot find elsewhere.
Critics of using media as a reference for historical studies believe that the dramatization inherent in the industry can distort facts. Directors may add action or romantic scenes to increase viewership, potentially misleading audiences. For instance, the series “Cleopatra” inaccurately portrayed the protagonist with black skin, deviating from historical truth.
Conversely, movies and television shows can offer scholars a vivid backdrop for the events they study. Scriptwriters often conduct extensive research, providing a portrayal of proven historical events. “Kingdom of Heaven,” set in the Middle Ages, depicts Salah al-Din and his leadership, offering insights into that era.
In conclusion, while acknowledging the potential for added drama, I support the use of movies and television shows as a reference in historical research, provided they are approached with a critical eye.